The Ladies are excited to announce our Worst Date Ever Series. Over the next 2 weeks we will post our dating horrors for your enjoyment. We know our lovely Readers have some dating doozies to share. Leave a comment on any Worst Date Ever post in the next 2 weeks and the Reader with the best Worst Date Ever story will win a freebie giveaway! ***We will not accept profanity, real names or private details (like the google street view of the person’s house...that's just weird).
By the time we reach our thirties, it's safe to say that all of us have been on a date so ridiculous that it becomes the stuff of legend among our friends. So have a seat and read my story: The Tale of Mr. Arugula.
I found Mr. A on match.com. It wasn't clear from his pictures whether he was attractive, but his profile described an interesting, genteel character who I thought would be worth talking to. We started exchanging messages, and I learned that he was buying a house in one of my favorite neighborhoods in Richmond (check). We also discovered a mutual interest in farmers markets and cooking (check), and he told me he wanted to get to the farmers market that weekend to buy some arugula for a new recipe he was trying.
After a few email exchanges, Mr. A and I made a plan to grab Sunday brunch at The Roosevelt and then go to the farmers market from there. I still couldn't tell if Mr. A would be attractive, but this seemed like a great way to spend a Sunday morning regardless. Unfortunately, I was completely wrong!
I arrived about 5 minutes early for our date and got a table--the last available table in the place, in fact. I decided to wait to order a drink until Mr. A got there, as I thought drinking alone might make a poor first impression. As I sat at the Roosevelt by myself, Mr. A texted me that he would be about 10 minutes late (I do have to give him credit for at least letting me know). As it turned out, Mr. A didn't actually know where the Roosevelt was, and he had parked about a mile away and was now walking.
Lesson 1: If you're taking a date to an unfamiliar location, make absolutely sure you know how to get there before your date!
When Mr. A finally arrived, the attraction question was immediately answered. On his profile Mr. A had claimed to be 3 inches taller than I am; in real life he was about half an inch shorter.
Lesson 2: Do NOT lie about your height. You're allowed to like women with breasts, and I'm allowed to like men who are at least 6' tall.
As we ordered brunch, I realized that Mr. A was not getting any sort of adult beverage. Part of me was glad I hadn't jumped the gun on Boozy Brunch, while the other part of me was wishing I'd chugged a Bloody Mary before he arrived.
Lesson 3: If it says on your online profile that you drink, and you take a woman on a brunch date, brunch includes alcohol.
As we settled into our date, I began to wonder if Mr. A had written his own Match profile. Mr. Gentility was quite a conversational dud in person. At one point, trying to make small talk, I told Mr. A that another of The Ladies was also there for brunch. I said, "My friend Viveka is over there with her... well I don't know what to call him these days, because I actually thought they broke up, but anyway, they're here too." Mr. A's reaction: "Oh, so you're a gossip queen." Um, what? Already knowing that this date was a bust, I replied, "No, if I were a gossip queen I would tell you the gory details of why they broke up, even though you don't know them."
Thank goodness the food at
The Roosevelt is tasty, because Mr. A had haplessly lost his wallet at some point that morning and I ended up buying brunch. Now our date was just becoming a comedy of errors. I ended up giving Mr. A a ride to his car a mile away, at which time he found his wallet and awkwardly paid me back for brunch. Although we were clearly not hitting it off, Mr. A insisted that we follow through with our plan to go to the farmers market. We drove down to 17th Street so he could get his coveted arugula.
(Lesson 4: Double and triple check that you have your wallet before you meet up with a date--this goes for both guys and girls!)
As we were walking up to the market, Mr. A encountered a couple who clearly didn't remember him. He had to reintroduce himself to the guy, who was like "Oh yeah, hey buddy!" Mr. A then said, "Hey, sorry I never paid you back that money I borrowed from you, I promise to get it to you soon." Oh My God, what? This dude doesn't even recognize you, and you owe him money??
There was no arugula at the farmers market. The farmers told us that arugula was not in fact in season just yet. However, Mr. A was bound and determined to get himself some arugula, so he decided we should continue to look for it at the Pole Green farmers market. As in, the one 30 minutes away in Mechanicsville. It was bad enough that Mr. A didn't realize I couldn't wait to end our date, but on top of that, he asked me to drive the two of us around, because he had bought a bunch of furniture for his house and had no room in his own vehicle.
(Lesson 5: Never put yourself in a situation where you can't offer your date a ride.)
Because Mr. A's car was full of furniture, he didn't want to leave it parked on the street in Church Hill. At this point, he asked me if he could follow me to my house, leave his car parked there, and ride with me to Mechanicsville. I absolutely, positively should have said No, but by then, I was so shell shocked by how ridiculous this entire encounter was that I begrudgingly said yes. (
Lesson 6: Never invite yourself to a woman's home on a first date. Can you say creepy??)
I led Mr. A to the general vicinity of my apartment and directed him to park his car nearby. When he got back in my car for the trip to Pole Green, I told him that the market would be the last stop on our date, as I had to meet up with friends afterwards. Although we were already en route, this must have been the moment he realized I didn't like him, as he snarkily said, "Well you can just let me out now if you have to go."
Conversation went downhill from there as we trekked to Pole Green. In less than an hour I learned that Mr. A was not a sports fan (huge dealbreaker for me), did not like my favorite restaurant because it was "too expensive" (at less than $10 per meal per person), and did not go to bars, preferring to drink alcohol he purchased from Walmart at home (yes, he literally said that). Our lack of Boozy Brunch was making much more sense now. Mr. A was a complete cheapskate who had somehow faked the classy preferences he claimed on his Match profile. How did I end up in my car, driving this weirdo to Mechanicsville?! Our date ended unceremoniously when we finally got back to my neighborhood and I dropped him off. By this time, even clueless Mr. A had figured out that there would be no second date.
Months later, another of The Ladies got sucked into Mr. A's bogus Match persona and scheduled a date with him. Fortunately we had dinner that week, and as soon as she showed me who she was going out with the next night, I said "Noooooo! That's Mr. Arugula!!" She quickly texted him to cancel.
The Tale of Mr. Arugula taught me some important lessons in online dating. First of all, never commit to more than one activity. (As
Viveka mentioned, she doesn't even do dinner on a first date). My date with Mr. A went horribly awry because of our premature agreement to go farmers market shopping together. Secondly, if you find yourself on a completely terrible date, (wo)man up and bail out. I wasted several hours of a beautiful Sunday with Mr. A because I didn't feel comfortable telling him honestly that I had no interest in being there anymore. Lastly, order the Bloody Mary. You just might need it.